Scimitar Sl-2

Listed Copies of this Book

There are no copies of this book listed

Some Other Books by this Author

• Kilo ClassChina has ordered ten Russian-built Kilo Class submarines, but this order is the last thing the Pentagon will allow. With the subs in Chinese hands, Beijing will gain control of the Taiwan Strait. The order goes out from...
  No. of listed copies: 1
• The Shark MutinyVeteran techno-thriller writer Robinson's fifth novel pairs Arnold Morgan, the aging but still powerful national security adviser who stars in the author's previous titles (Nimitz Class, Kilo Class) with a new young ...
  No. of listed copies: 2
• The Shark MutinyIt is the year 2006, and a succession of massive underwater explosions has left three of the world’s largest oil tankers burning fiercely in the middle of the Strait of Hormuz. United States military intelligence concl...
  No. of listed copies: 1
• Nimitz ClassThe US Nimitz Class carrier is a state-of-the-art war machine. Suddenly she disappears from the radar screens, and vanishes with all her crew. The hunt is on for the killers, and the entire force of the West's defence sw...
  No. of listed copies: 1
• H.m.s. UnseenMilitary Thriller
  No. of listed copies: 0

see all books for Patrick Robinson

Other Books in this Genre

• The Last Sanctuary by Craig Holden
  A Gulf War veteran is living on the edge of society, falsely accused of murder and plunged into America's unde...
  No. of listed copies: 0
• The Mysterious Commission (penguin Crime Fiction) by Michael Innes
  A bizarre and perilous adventure unfolds when artist Charles Honeybath, inspired by the offer of a huge fee, a...
  No. of listed copies: 1
• Mistress Of The Art Of Death by Ariana Franklin
  In Cambridge a child has been hideously murdered and other children have disappeared. A renowned investigator,...
  No. of listed copies: 0
• On The Edge by Michael Ridpath
  How close to the edge would you go? From his past as an RAF fighter pilot to his job as a bond trader in the C...
  No. of listed copies: 0
• The Little House by Philippa Gregory
  It was easy for Elizabeth. She married the man she loved. It was harder for Ruth. She married Elizabeth's son ...
  No. of listed copies: 1

See all listings in Thriller

REVIEWS

This book is currently rated: out of 5 by 1 people

Rate this book: 5 4 3 2 1

1 of 1

Reviewer: longplay

Rating:

Review:
I’ve read all of Robinson’s previous books and so I bought this without a thought. His previous works, all based around submarines and special forces missions, have made some entertaining reading with some thrilling concepts and interesting characters. In this book he has a great concept (terrorists threaten to flood the US eastern seaboard with a tsunami caused by blowing up a volcano in the Canary Islands) and the same bunch of characters has returned, but it didn’t live up to the previous books.

I didn’t like this book for a number of reasons. First, there’s Robinson’s over the top pro-American stance, which means he spends half the book jamming the idea that America is the greatest country on Earth down your throat. He’d done this in previous books, but not to the same degree. This may help the books sell in the US, but it does nothing for a global audience or, more importantly, the story. Then there are the characters. Robinson has used the same characters for several books, with the core few going back quite some time, but here they are over familiar and lazily written. There’s no development of the characters, or conflict or disagreement between them and instead of finding some replacement for his main character (who has now retired) he simply brings him out of retirement (and will do again for the next book it seems). Another thing I didn’t like was that he uses the book to voice his political orientation (I lost count of the number of times the characters bellyache about not having a hard line Republican president and they make the Democrats out to be some sort of hippy tribe). Politics are fine as part of the story, but fiction is not the place to make political statements. Consumerism is writ large in the book too. All of the characters are affluent white people (overwhelmingly men) and Robinson insists on discussing their delightful meals, expensive tastes and fine wines. This is a military thriller, we don’t give a toss if they all sit down to a delicate meal of pan-fried fish accompanied by a vintage wine, we want to know how they’re going to catch the terrorists. It feels like a statement about how rich and powerful they are and leaves a nasty taste in my mouth. Last, but not least, is the authors absurd desire to detail the most minuscule thing. The story involves the evacuation of the entire eastern United States. Add a little detail by all means, but don’t start listing individual works of art, or every museum and centre of excellence that stores irreplaceable items of artistic and historical significance, apart from being boring as hell, it smacks of boasting. Aside from which, if you cut it all out, the book would come in significantly shorter, meaning it was faster paced and more intense. Stopping the chase for the terrorists to detail the evacuation plans for 10 pages takes the edge off it somewhat. All in all it made me feel that I should be holding an American flag while reading it and that every time I opened the book a rendition of the Star Spangled Banner would play.

Personally, I wouldn’t recommend it as anything more than a holiday novel, the sort of book to read in the sun that won’t tax you. It’s popcorn in a book format, swathed in the Stars and Stripes. As propaganda for how great America is, how fantastic their armed forces are and how the Republicans keep the interests of the US (and it’s rich, white citizens) in the forefront of their minds at all times, it’s a great book. For anyone who realises there is a world outside of North America, it’s worth avoiding. I won’t be rushing out to buy his next one.

Bizarrely, the previous title for the book was Tsunami, but his publishers didn’t think anyone knew what it meant and that they wouldn’t get it. I don’t know about the US, but the rest of the world knew what a tsunami was long before the tragedy that struck last December.

Login or register to review this book.